The second most common reason
that Canadians lie awake at night, at least according to an Abacus poll from
last year, is Health Care.
Fully
fourteen percent of Canadians (compared to over 50% in the United States) sometimes
lie awake worrying about health care: whether they will get it, whether it will
be high quality, whether they will be able to get a doctor, whether they have
to wait too long, and whether or not they will be able to afford the meds that
are prescribed.
I’ll
get back to that fourteen percent in a minute. But first, I want to put it in
the context of a story found in the Bible. In Mark 8, Jesus heals a blind man in Bethsaida. People had brought him to Jesus and asked Jesus to touch him. That’s it. They
thought that would be enough.
But
it isn’t. Jesus has to spit into his hands, and rub the saliva in the man’s
eyes. Then, when Jesus asks him if he can see, the blind man doesn’t say, “Yes,
thank you Lord!” No, he says, “well, sort of. A little bit.” So, Jesus tries again.
He lays hands on him—whether with or without more spit isn’t clear. Then Jesus
stares at him. And finally, the man can see again.
It
is all a bit strange. Jesus seems to fumble this miracle. Instead of a fancy
deke at the end of a breakaway, Jesus has to bang at the puck a few times in
front of the net to make it go in. It isn’t very pretty. Bible scholars scratch
their heads and wonder what this story might mean, why it is told this way.
Mostly,
they think the story of the blind man is actually a parable that Mark has made
up for Jesus to act out. The blind man, in this reading, is really a stand-in for
the disciples. You see, like the blind man, the disciples can’t see Jesus for
who he really is; or they can only make out Jesus vaguely, as if he were a tree
rather than a person. Both the story before this healing, and the story after, focus on the stubborn blindness of the disciples when it came to seeing
who Jesus is.
So,
before the healing of the blind man, Jesus is upset because in spite of the
fact—according to the story Mark tells—in spite of the fact that he has
miraculously fed 4,000, and then 5,000 people on a single sack lunch, the
disciples are worried about food. They don’t get it. So, Jesus asks them: “Do
you have eyes and fail to see?”
And
then, after this miracle, Jesus asks the disciples who he thinks he is. Their
answers are ridiculous. John the Baptist. Elijah. Maybe a prophet. Maybe
someone else. All the answers are wrong! Even after being reminded of the
miraculous feedings, and even after the healing of the blind man, the disciples
don’t see Jesus for who he is, and what he has done. And the rest of the
chapter, which we didn’t read, is more of the same. Peter finally says, “well,
you might be the Messiah.” But when Jesus says he is going to be a suffering
Messiah, Peter says, “no way!” And Jesus, disgusted, says to Peter, “Get behind
me, Satan.”
The
disciples live with Jesus, listen to Jesus, watch Jesus, but they don’t see who
he really is, and they don’t see the bigger picture. They want a wonder working
magician Jesus. But the real Jesus turns out to be a savior by example, who demonstrates
in his life and in his death that people are worth dying for. It is one of the
hardest Biblical lessons, one that we, like the disciples don’t much like. But
there it is. Do you see it?
But
now I want to get back to the whole “lying awake about health care” thing. Like
the disciples, one of the issues we sometimes struggle with is a failure to see
the miracles all around us. We are, are usually surprised when things don’t
work out as quickly or as easily as we would like them to. So perhaps some
context will help.
In
the New Testament, Jesus does about forty miracles, including about 30 or 35
healings, depending on how you count them up. And then, depending on whether we
are a United Church person or a Fundamentalist Baptist or maybe a Roman
Catholic, we sometimes sit back in our arm chairs and argue about whether or
not these miracles really happened. That’s okay, as far as it goes.
But
forget those forty miracles for a minute. What I’d like to ask, this morning,
is this. What about the millions, perhaps billions of healing miracles in
Canada and around the world that we take for granted every day? Do we stop,
often enough, to admire what is happening all around us?
Here
is what I mean—just a brief little story. When William was about three years
old, and Irene and I were both graduate students, we visited some friends for
an evening of Risk—a board game. The tea pot was on the floor, beside a couch,
on a hot air register. Meanwhile, William, was climbing the couch like a monkey,
wrapped in three layers of pajamas because it was cold.
The
next thing you know, William falls off the couch, onto the tea pot, and is
badly burned, to the third degree, around his shoulder and under his arm. We
couldn’t help him at first, because we had to take the PJs off, and that took a
while, and it was excruciatingly painful for William and we rushed him to the
hospital which was a few blocks away. It was awful.
What
happened next is interesting. Though there were ointments and meds, tears and
bandages, hand wringing and regrets for weeks after, the one thing we never
worried about was whether or not William would live. Of course, he would live.
We never doubted it.
But
here is the thing. One hundred years ago, in the 1920s, simple burns like
William’s were the third leading cause of accidental death in the USA, and so
probably in Canada too. Just 100 years ago, in the 1920s.
But
there is more. One hundred years ago the number one cause of all deaths in the
was diarrhea, followed by TB and pneumonia. Do you know anyone who has died of
diarrhea?
There
is more. Two hundred years ago, nearly 50% of children worldwide died by the
age of five from diseases and accidents. By one hundred years ago, mostly due
to the discovery of germs and the need for cleanliness, that had dropped to 33%
of children who died, worldwide, from diseases and accidents before the age of
five. Today—including the whole world, not just the developed West, that number
is less than 5%. Do you see this miracle of bread and loaves, of the blind
seeing? Do you understand its import and significance? Have you, unlike the
disciples, stopped to think what it means?
Of
course, we lie awake with our personal worries about medical care—most of us,
in fact, lie awake with such worries well into our eighties or nineties, and
almost unheard-of age to live to 100 years ago—but an age we all reasonably
hope for now. Our mortality, our aches and pains, our worries about health and
health care shouldn’t be minimized or dismissed.
But
what also ought to keep us awake at night is the real miracle of what we do
have. Amazing, incredible, nearly unimaginable—at least 100 years ago—health
care.
Our
health care system—like Jesus’ bumbling cure of a man’s blindness, in our text—is
not perfect. Our system is not always speedy, especially when it comes to
elective care. Yes, meds are expensive, and achingly out of reach for too many
Canadians. And naturally, we can always count on the newspapers to focus on a
few medical cases that went wrong, sometimes spectacularly so, rather than the
millions of people who are patched up, healed, or sent on their way better
every year.
But
no one today is dying of polio, or small pox, or typhoid, or diarrhea. Heart
attacks are not a death sentence. Cancer, a disease of old age, mostly, is
being beaten back, bit by bit. Most infections do not kill. We think of kidney
transplants—even heart transplants—as almost routine.
It’s
amazing. It’s beautiful. It’s a health care system that isn’t perfect—just as
none of us is perfect. But still, wow. Look around. This is a good time to be
alive. We don’t have merely 40 or 45 miracles; modern medicine has given us billions.
It’s
a beautiful, reassuring thing. Thank God.
Thanks, John, for reminding us of the everyday miracles all around us. (You also astutely avoided getting hung up in debating the historicity of the miracles attributed to Jesus. If you ever do decide to go down that road in a sermon, you might want to take a look at the discussion in 2 or 3 of the sermons by Marcus Borg that have been published in the recent posthumous collection Days of Awe and Wonder.)
ReplyDeleteIn addition to noticing how miraculous our health care would have seemed to our forebears, I think we might also want to consider this as a sign of “the realm of God” emerging in our midst. The fact that so many of these improvements in health care have become universal in so many places should be a cause for rejoicing and hope, as well as awe. (Said he, writing from the U.S. where much wasted energy goes into defending the inequities in even basic health care and people we know are foregoing needed hip replacements and the like because they can’t afford the co-pay.)
Minor quibble with the post: Polio has disappeared from the population in every country but one: in Pakistan there were over three dozen cases reported in 2016. While it may be true that there are few or no deaths from polio, the continued presence of the virus in Pakistan is the reason that we have to continue vaccination programs world-wide.
The efforts to promote vaccination, which succeeded in eradicating polio from Afghanistan in 2015, have been hindered in Pakistan by anti-Western militants who claim that the vaccines are a Western ruse to harm the population. (This may be related to the CIA using a fake vaccination campaign in 2011 as a ruse to collect DNA from Osama bin Laden’s children in.)
As for typhoid fever: although deaths from typhoid are very rare in the developed world, about 300 people get typhoid fever in the United States each year - most of whom have recently traveled to a country lacking the clean drinking water and sanitation systems that we take for granted (another miracle!). About 22 million cases of typhoid fever and 200,000 related deaths occur worldwide each year. In Canada, the vaccine is only recommended for people traveling to countries with active or recent outbreaks
Smallpox appears to be fully eradicated: the vaccine is no longer being made available. Hallelujah!
p.s. sorry to be so late in responding to your post – I was not receiving notifications and have re-subscribed using a different email account to see if that solves the problem.